Fancy Feast Broths Review: The Ultimate Treat for Picky Cats?

Let’s be honest, we cat owners are ruled by our feline overlords, especially when it comes to their food bowl. My cat, Leo, has days where he’ll turn his nose up at his favorite kibble for reasons known only to him. It’s frustrating, and it also makes me worry if he’s getting enough hydration. That’s what sent me searching for a solution, and I stumbled upon the Purina Fancy Feast Broths Classics Collection. It’s not a full meal, but a lickable, pourable broth designed to make regular food irresistible. But does it actually work? I decided to find out.

These little pouches are essentially a gourmet soup for your cat. The idea is simple: pour it over their existing food to add a burst of flavor and moisture, or serve it on its own as a special treat. For a picky eater or a cat that shies away from their water bowl, this seemed like a perfect little hack.

A variety pack of Fancy Feast Broths cat food toppers in their pouches.

What Makes Fancy Feast Broths Stand Out?

After trying these out with Leo, a few key features really impressed me. It’s more than just flavored water; there’s some real thought put into the recipe.

Real, Recognizable Ingredients: When you tear open a pouch, you can actually see shreds of real tuna, shrimp, or salmon. It’s not a mystery mush. The Classics Collection includes flavors like Tuna & Shrimp, Tuna & Anchovies, and Wild Salmon & Veggies, so there’s variety to keep things interesting.

Clean, Grain-Free Formula: There are no grains, by-products, fillers, or artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives. As someone who reads pet food labels obsessively, this is a huge plus. It feels like a clean, simple treat.

Hydration Hero: The main component is a silky broth. This is fantastic for adding extra moisture to your cat’s diet, which is crucial for kidney and urinary tract health, especially for cats who primarily eat dry food.

Perfectly Portioned Pouches: The single-serve pouches are incredibly convenient. There’s no need to store leftovers in the fridge. You just tear, pour, and you’re done.

How to Serve It Up

Using these broths is as easy as it gets, but here’s how we do it for maximum enjoyment:

  1. Give it a little shake: Before opening, gently shake the pouch to make sure the broth and solids are mixed well.
  2. Tear and Pour: Tear the top off the pouch and pour it into your cat’s favorite bowl.
  3. Serve Your Way: You have options!
    • As a Topper: Pour it directly over your cat’s dry or wet food to entice them to eat. This is my go-to method.
    • As a Treat: Serve it on its own in a small dish between meals. Leo loves this as an afternoon “snack.”

Important Tip: Remember, this is a complement, not a complete and balanced meal. It doesn’t have all the vitamins and minerals your cat needs for their daily diet, so it should always be served in addition to their regular food.

What Other Cat Parents Are Saying

With a stellar 4.6 out of 5 stars from over 6,000 reviews, it’s clear I’m not the only one who’s found success with these broths.

Jessica R. (5/5 stars) says, “My 15-year-old cat has gotten so picky in her old age, and these broths are a lifesaver. She licks the bowl clean every single time. It’s the only thing that gets her excited for mealtime now.”

David K. (4/5 stars) mentions, “My cat absolutely loves the broth but sometimes leaves the fish chunks behind. I wish it was a little cheaper for the amount you get, but it’s worth it to make sure he’s getting extra water. A great product for picky drinkers.”

The general consensus is that cats go crazy for the taste, and it’s especially popular with senior cats and those with dental issues who find it easier to lick than chew. The main critique tends to be the price point for what is essentially a supplement.

Pros and Cons at a Glance

Pros Cons
✅ Highly palatable for picky eaters ❌ Not a complete meal, only a topper
✅ Adds essential moisture to their diet ❌ Can be a bit pricey per serving
✅ Made with high-quality, real ingredients ❌ Some cats may only lick the broth
✅ Convenient, easy-to-use pouches

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Q: Is this a full meal for my cat? A: No, the Fancy Feast Broths are intended as a complement or food topper. They are not nutritionally complete and should be served alongside your cat’s regular balanced diet.

Q: My cat is extremely picky. Is it worth trying? A: Based on overwhelmingly positive reviews from owners of picky cats, it’s definitely worth a shot. The variety pack is a great way to see which flavors your cat prefers before committing to a larger purchase.

Q: Can I give this to my kitten? A: This product is formulated specifically for adult cats. For kittens, it’s always best to consult with your veterinarian before introducing new foods or supplements to their diet.

Final Verdict: Who Should Buy This?

The Fancy Feast Broths Classics Collection is a fantastic product for a few specific types of cat owners. If you have a picky eater, a senior cat who struggles with hard food, or a cat that you know doesn’t drink enough water, this is an excellent addition to your pantry. It’s also perfect for anyone who just wants to pamper their pet with a delicious, high-quality treat.

However, if you’re on a tight budget or looking for an all-in-one meal solution, this might not be the most economical choice. But as a problem-solver for finicky felines and poor drinkers, it’s a clear winner in my book. Leo certainly gives it two paws up.

Ready to treat your cat? You can find the variety pack here: Buy on Amazon Purina Fancy Feast Broths Classics Collection